Side-by-side comparison based on 9,994 products tracked by Bazenda. Updated daily.
Head-to-Head
Key metrics compared side by side. All data is from real products tracked on Bazenda.
American Eagle is more budget-friendly with an average price of $32 vs Madewell's $99. American Eagle runs sales more often: 65% of their products are currently discounted compared to Madewell's 34%. When American Eagle does discount, it tends to be bigger, averaging 33% off.
Category Breakdown
Average prices by product category. The lower price is highlighted in green.
| Category | American Eagle Products | American Eagle Avg | Madewell Products | Madewell Avg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| loungewear | 1552 | $27 | — | — |
| denim | 1485 | $31 | — | — |
| tops | 973 | $29 | 700 | $68 |
| swimwear | 674 | $23 | — | — |
| shoes | 557 | $86 | 63 | $166 |
| activewear | 368 | $26 | — | — |
| lingerie | 321 | $19 | 35 | $49 |
| dresses | 288 | $42 | 161 | $135 |
| bottoms | 266 | $29 | 295 | $100 |
| jewelry | 244 | $14 | 185 | $61 |
Price Distribution
How products are spread across price ranges. Shows where each brand concentrates.
American Eagle
Madewell
Best Deals Right Now
Top discounted products from each brand, sorted by discount percentage.
Explore Both Brands
Browse all products and track prices with Bazenda.